Not all lawyers are created equal, especially when it comes to OUI defense. The attorney you choose can make the difference between conviction and acquittal, between jail time and freedom, between a criminal record and a clean slate. Understanding what to look for ensures you get the specialized representation you need.
Why Specialization Matters
OUI defense is a specialized area of law requiring specific knowledge and experience. You need someone who understands breathalyzer science, field sobriety test standardization, police procedures, and the nuances of Massachusetts OUI law.
A general practice attorney who handles divorces, real estate closings, and an occasional criminal case won’t have this depth of knowledge. They might miss defenses a specialist would identify immediately. They might not know which expert witnesses to call or how to cross-examine a police officer effectively.
Board Certified Specialists in DUI/OUI Defense Law have met rigorous standards demonstrating their expertise. They’ve handled a minimum number of OUI cases, passed a comprehensive examination, and received peer recognition of their skill. This certification isn’t required to practice OUI defense, but it’s a strong indicator of expertise.
Experience with Local Courts
Massachusetts has different courts in different counties, and each court has its own culture, procedures, and informal practices. An attorney familiar with your specific courthouse understands how things work there.
They know the judges and their tendencies. They have working relationships with prosecutors. They understand which arguments resonate in that courthouse and which fall flat. This local knowledge provides strategic advantages that out-of-town attorneys lack.
Ask prospective attorneys how many cases they’ve handled in the specific courthouse where your case will be heard. Someone who regularly practices there brings valuable insights.
Trial Experience
Many OUI cases are resolved through plea agreements, but yours might need to go to trial. You want an attorney who’s actually tried OUI cases in front of juries, not someone who always settles.
Trial experience matters for two reasons. First, if your case does go to trial, you need someone skilled at jury selection, opening statements, cross-examination, and closing arguments. These are specific skills developed through practice.
Second, prosecutors know which attorneys actually try cases and which ones always plead out. If your attorney has a reputation for going to trial and winning, prosecutors are more likely to offer favorable plea deals to avoid trial.
Scientific Knowledge
OUI defense increasingly involves challenging scientific evidence: breathalyzer results, blood test procedures, DRE (Drug Recognition Expert) evaluations. Your attorney needs to understand the science well enough to cross-examine experts and identify flaws in testing procedures.
Do they understand partition ratios and how they affect breathalyzer accuracy? Can they explain the absorption and elimination phases of alcohol metabolism? Do they know the standardization requirements for field sobriety tests?
This scientific knowledge separates effective OUI attorneys from lawyers who treat these cases like any other criminal matter. The science is crucial, and your attorney must be fluent in it.
Access to Expert Witnesses
Sometimes defending an OUI case requires expert testimony—a toxicologist to explain why the breathalyzer result is questionable, a medical expert to discuss conditions affecting field sobriety tests, a former police officer to critique arrest procedures.
Experienced OUI attorneys have relationships with credible experts and know when expert testimony can strengthen a defense. They understand the costs involved and can recommend whether an expert makes sense for your specific case.
Clear Communication Style
Legal proceedings are confusing enough without an attorney who speaks in incomprehensible jargon. You need someone who explains things clearly, keeps you informed about case developments, and returns your calls and emails promptly.
During your initial consultation, pay attention to whether the attorney explains concepts in ways you understand. Do they listen to your questions and answer them directly? Or do they talk over you and make you feel stupid for not understanding?
Good communication isn’t just courtesy—it’s essential for effective representation. You need to understand your options, the risks and benefits of different strategies, and what’s happening at each stage of your case.
Honest Assessment
Be wary of any attorney who guarantees a specific outcome. No lawyer can promise to get your case dismissed or ensure you won’t face penalties. The legal system doesn’t work that way.
A good attorney will give you an honest assessment based on the facts. They’ll explain potential defenses and their likelihood of success. They’ll discuss realistic outcomes rather than making promises they can’t keep.
If an attorney tells you exactly what you want to hear—”Don’t worry, I’ll get this dismissed easily”—be skeptical. OUI cases are complex, and outcomes depend on numerous factors including evidence, court procedures, and judges’ decisions.
Reasonable Fees
Legal representation costs money, and OUI attorneys’ fees vary considerably. The cheapest option isn’t always the best, but the most expensive isn’t necessarily the best either.
Understand what’s included in the fee: does it cover trial if necessary, or just the initial court appearances? Does it include motion practice, expert witnesses, or DMV hearings? Are there additional costs you should anticipate?
Some attorneys offer payment plans or flat fees. Others bill hourly. Make sure you understand the fee structure and what you’re getting for your money.
Questions to Ask During Consultations
When meeting with prospective attorneys, come prepared with questions: How many OUI cases have you handled? What percentage go to trial versus plea deals? Are you Board Certified in DUI/OUI Defense? Do you regularly practice in my courthouse? What are potential defenses in my case? What are realistic outcomes given the facts?
Take notes during these consultations. You’ll probably meet with several attorneys, and the information will blur together if you don’t write it down.
Trust Your Instincts
Finally, pay attention to your gut feeling. Do you feel comfortable with this person? Do they treat you with respect? Do you trust them to fight for your interests?
You’ll be working closely with your attorney through a stressful time. Choose someone you trust and feel comfortable communicating with, not just someone with impressive credentials.
Don’t Wait
The sooner you hire an attorney, the better. Evidence needs to be preserved, witnesses need to be contacted, and important deadlines need to be met. Don’t let weeks pass while you decide.
Most OUI attorneys offer free initial consultations. Take advantage of these to meet several lawyers, compare their approaches, and make an informed decision. Then commit to one and get started on your defense.
Contact Milligan & Higgins for a free consultation or second opinion. Please send us an email: Intake@milliganhiggins.com or call 781-878-1231.
Click HERE to download our OUI Survival Guide
To post an Amazon Review of our OUI Survival Guide, please scan the QR Code:
